In reviewing a new model, CarsGuide looks at eight key criteria — Price and features (value), Design (form and function), Practicality (space and tech), Under the bonnet (engine/motor and transmission), Efficiency (fuel/energy consumption and range), Driving (impressions behind the wheel), Safety (active and passive) and Ownership (warranty and servicing).
And each car is assessed in the context of its market segment and key competitors. Hence our Guide segmentation.
As the name implies, a FamilyGuide review emphasises day-to-day practicality, safety, economy and everything else that makes for a great family truckster.
Read more about top cars of 2024
And so it goes for AdventureGuide (for off-roaders and the ‘off-road curious’), TradieGuide (light commercials for business users), EVGuide (hybrid and pure-electric options) and UrbanGuide (city and suburban dwellers).
So, for example, a two-seat supercar wedge like the McLaren 750S is never going to be as practical as the Kia Carnival people mover. But the real question is, does it match — or better — the likes of a Ferrari 296 GTB or Porsche’s 911 Turbo S?
And while the Carnival won’t come near the Big Mac for performance, the more relevant yardstick is a Hyundai Staria or VW Multivan.
So, with that in mind, and close to 450 new product reviews done and dusted across all segments for 2024, which cars came out on top? Here are the Top 10 (plus one) cars for the year as judged by our panel of expert reviewers.
Comments