Renault Megane 2012 review

Having a good car isn't good enough to be a winner in the small car class. Just ask Renault, whose Megane is earning a trickle of interest amid a torrent of sales. Put that down to lack of knowledge in the brand.

Renault is starting off a small base in Australia and is still educating the public that French flair is a no-cost option, not an extra-cost one. In the Megane buyers get a solidly built hatch that rides well and has enough standard gear to be value for money. The downside is a continuously variable transmission in the petrol models that drones worse that a seminar speaker. The diesel's a better engine but is too noisy under load.

VALUE

The bottom line is $26,000 buys a base model Megane Dynamique with 16-inch alloys, a six-speed manual gearbox and most of the features you want except satellite navigation. That's about what it costs for a Mazda3 MaxxSport but the Mazda does come with satnav. Spend $2500 more for a Megane with the 1.5-litre turbodiesel and a six-speed auto. The Privilege spec level raises the bar by $4000 for the petrol and $5000 for the diesel.

TECHNOLOGY

The dual-clutch automated manual transmission works well with the diesel. There's a moment of hesitation off the line but the torque rolls on early and gives the hatch decent performance around town. It doesn't have the punch of a Ford Focus TDCi but it also uses a litre less diesel every 100km, with Renault claiming fuel use of 4.5 litres/100km.

STYLING

The front end of the Renault is distinctive without straying too far from the accepted small car formula. The bumper sweeps up to the top of the wheel arches where it neatly blends in with the wraparound lights. Rear seat legroom is on the tight side to be packing two adults in the rear for a lengthy trip but the boot's 360 litres of space is easy to load.

The interior is just starting to date - and Renault persists in putting the sound system controls on a block behind the steering wheel where they can't be seen or easily used. Putting a cupholder in front of the USB input isn't a "Eureka" moment, either.

SAFETY

The Megane was the first small car to earn a five-star rating from Euro NCAP. That was five years ago and shows how well engineered the Renault is. Six airbags are supplemented by stability and traction control and there are seat belt reminders for both front seats.

DRIVING

Put the boot in to the Megane and it punches back well above its weight. The transmission is geared for economy but will quickly drop down a couple of cogs if there's enough right-foot pressure.  And the brakes are close to best in class. The 280mm front and 260mm rear discs are consistent and effective at any speeds, though they start to bite earlier in the pedal travel than most Asian cars.

Ignoring the diesel clatter, the 1.5-litre turbodiesel is the engine of choice. The 2.0-litre petrol is more than OK but uses too much fuel. That can't be said of the diesel - Carsguide averaged 6.0 litres/100km. That's above the claimed figure but still impressive for a car carrying four in the urban jungle.

The seats are comfortable and the vision forward and rear is better than average, meaning the Megane ticks about every box you can ask it to. Better noise isolation is about all I'd want.

VERDICT

A five-year warranty sweetens an already good deal for the Megane. It isn't going to outsell the Corolla but is a smart alternative for those who don't want to run with the pack.