Mini Cooper VS Holden Spark
Mini Cooper
Likes
- Great design inside and out
- Outstanding multimedia system
- Brilliant driving experience
Dislikes
- Expensive
- No spare tyre
- Drab rear-seat packaging
Holden Spark
Likes
- A cut above from behind the wheel
- Plenty of cool tech
Dislikes
- Not cheap for its segment
- Lacks niceties for backseat passengers
Summary
Mini Cooper
In 1959 the British Motor Corporation (BMC) unveiled the first Mini to stunned amazement.
The mastermind of Alec Issigonis in response to soaring oil prices, it revolutionised small-car engineering, packaging and design on one hand, yet was as cheap and cheerful as any previous entry-level Morris on the other, to become an era-defining cultural phenomenon.
That changed after BMW bought Mini to reinvent it as a far-pricier range of larger, brattish retro-style hatchbacks, followed by convertible, wagon, coupe and SUV variants later on.
Read more about
- Pricing locked in for new city car: 2025 Mini Cooper five-door priced to fight Mercedes-Benz A-Class, Audi A1 and Fiat 500
- Striking new electric car confirmed for Oz: 2025 Mini Aceman price and specifications locked in as it takes aim at the Cupra Born, Volvo EX30 and coming Kia EV3
- Mini's hottest model to debut at famous endurance race: 2025 Mini Cooper S John Cooper Works is coming in petrol and electric car forms with the Hyundai i20 N and VW Polo GTI in its sights
Which actually helped when an electric version of BMW’s third-generation (F56) three-door (3dr) arrived as the SE in 2020. Ironically it became one of the less-expensive electric vehicles (EVs) available, evoking some of the original’s breakthrough spirit.
Now, in 2024, things get complicated.
The F56 has evolved into the restyled and elongated F66 fourth-gen Cooper petrol range, while the old SE has given way to an also-larger but completely different pure-EV model, in Cooper 3dr and imminent Aceman 5dr crossover/hatch guises. These latest Minis aren’t as much twins as doppelgangers.
Confused? Intrigued? You should be. But despite some reservations, the electric Cooper (tested here) might be the most brilliant Mini in seven decades.
| Safety rating | — |
|---|---|
| Engine Type | — |
| Fuel Type | Electric |
| Fuel Efficiency | —L/100km |
| Seating | — |
Holden Spark
Andrew Chesterton road tests and reviews the updated Holden Spark LT with specs, fuel consumption and verdict.
The micro-car segment in Australia has driven off a cliff. We are shunning our smallest cars in a way we never have before, and nobody seems to be entirely sure why.
The strength of the second-hand market is one suspected culprit, while another is the tempting price point of vehicles that are one size bigger, with city-car shoppers able to upsize for relative peanuts.
Whatever the reason, the segment is stuck in neutral and halfway along Struggle Street. It needs a spark. And Holden's hoping theirs is just the ticket.
Now you might recognise it as a Barina, but Holden dropped that part of the moniker when this new model launched in March. It is now simply known as the Holden Spark, tested here in top-spec LT guise and wearing a sticker price of $18,990. It sits above only the entry-level, bargain-basement LS ($13,990 manual, $15,690 automatic) in the two-model Spark range.
Designed and built in Korea, the Spark seems to have little to do with our unique marketplace, but Holden promises us this new model couldn't be more dinky-di if it ran on vegemite. Australia had crucial input into its design in Korea, while Holden's Aussie engineers put the new model though its paces on the company's proving ground, tweaking the suspension and steering for Australia's road surfaces.
So the question now is, is the Spark bright enough to lure buyers back to the micro-car segment?
| Safety rating | |
|---|---|
| Engine Type | 1.4L |
| Fuel Type | Regular Unleaded Petrol |
| Fuel Efficiency | 5.8L/100km |
| Seating | 5 seats |
Verdict
Mini Cooper8.5/10
In SE guise at least, the new electric Cooper seems to have lost none of the sprightliness or dexterity of earlier iterations, yet has gained a greater bandwidth of refinement and sophistication.
Coupled with the pleasing styling and brilliant cabin, we’re very excited about BMW’s latest Mini. Even at its premium price, the Cooper is just about the most fun EV for the money.
Holden Spark7.6/10
The marvels of local engineering strike again: the Spark LT definitely feels a cut above some of its budget competition from behind the wheel. It is well-equipped, too, and packed with connectivity and technology features. In short, it could be just the spark Australia's city-car segment needs.
Would you consider a small city-car like the Spark? Tell us your thoughts in the comments below.
Click here to see more 2016 Holden Spark LT pricing and spec info.
Design
Mini Cooper
This Mini is arguably the purest and cleanest since the BMC Morris original. That’s because, while the 2006 and 2014 models were post-modern takes on the 2001 reboot, the new design seems more faithful to Issigonis’ vision.
Sharing only the octagonal grille motif with its other Cooper, Aceman and Countryman siblings, there’s a simple elegance to the styling, with proportions that look spot on.
Now banished from the 3dr are the clamshell bonnet, plastic wheel arch shroudings, pull-up door handles and other visual clutter - though thankfully not the frameless doors. This minimisation of fuss and ornamentation compared to past and other present BMW-era Minis is a welcome development.
Fun fact. The windscreen is now more angled to significantly improve the aerodynamic flow crucial to EV efficiency. Traditionalists, please don faces of disapproval here.
This Mini seems smaller than it is, though in reality the Cooper is roughly 30mm longer (both in body length and wheelbase), wider and taller than the old 3dr, continuing BMW’s mockery of the moniker. The length, width, height and wheelbase measurements have now blown out to 3858mm, 1756mm, 1460mm and 2526mm, respectively. Which does pay some dividends inside.
Holden Spark7/10
There's only so much that can be done with a car in this bracket (there's hardly an abundance of surface metal to play with), but Holden's Korean design team have done an admirable job of inserting some excitement into what is traditionally a fairly bland category.
A powerful front end, with two fog lights sitting below the headlights, is dominated by a vaguely Kia-esque grille. And when viewed side on, the Spark looks to be sitting low, courtesy of standard 15-inch alloys that fill the wheel arches and tarmac-kissing side skirting that runs front to back. Two fairly heavy body creases also break up the metal monotony, running along the front and rear doors.
It's an energetic-looking package, and even more youth appeal arrives courtesy of a huge array of personalisation options, with Holden promising 33 different changes a buyer can make, including the wheel inserts, wing mirror caps and roof rails.
Inside, the focus is more on connectivity than luxury, so you can expect fake leather, hard plastics and fairly ordinary seat cushioning, but it's all nicely put together, and the basic feel is broken up by some well-placed style elements, like the coloured insert that runs the length of the dash.
Practicality
Mini Cooper
This is a Mini. But it’s the roomiest one ever without back doors.
Drop yourself inside one and you’ll be struck by the sheer change going on. Retro familiarity dominated by brash innovation.
Yes, it still has comparatively upright pillars, a centrally-sited circular display and a row of toggle switches within an otherwise sparse fascia, but that’s where the similarities between classic-old and brand-new cease.
All eyes are drawn to the modest 240mm (9.4-inch) central OLED display, which seems overwhelmingly busy at first glance, but becomes clear in design, intuitive in layout and functional to use in no time. BMW’s experience here is industry-leading.
The Mini deploys bright colours and fun symbols to further help operators know what does what, where and why, making this playful and sophisticated in execution. If only all screen-based multimedia and vehicle settings were this logical. So much so, in fact, that even a limited number of toggle switches, alongside the welcome volume knob and gear selector, are enough. You won’t miss them.
Now, the driving position is first class as you might expect, with that sitting-upright-in-a-box-with-plenty-of-glass-all-round-you sensation that’s been part of the Mini experience for decades. And, in Favoured guise, the JCW buckets are superb.
The small, low-placed wheel feels right, forward vision is excellent, nothing is too much of a stretch away, storage is generous for a car this size (with a largish glove box included) and ventilation proved to be reassuringly effective in the Baltic-esque conditions we tested the car in.
Of course, being a Mini, the Cooper boasts personalisation and customisation galore, including for some compelling screen backgrounds (one reminiscent of the Morris era) and the inevitable ambient lighting, while the standard, synthetic trim and textures are amongst the most interesting in any car. And it’s all really well put together in terms of aesthetics and build quality.
What’s not to like?
Well, for starters, the glass roof lacks a cover and that’s daft in Australia. Even on a freezing Melbourne day, the sun’s glare can be too much. The side pillars are a blind spot hazard, making those standard lane-support driver-assist safety alerts essential, so don’t disable them. The between-seat cubby feels flimsy and has a lid facing the wrong way from the driver - that’s just plain lazy, BMW. And we’re glad the head-up display directly ahead of the driver is included because the digital speedo in the centre screen strays too far from some drivers’ comfortable sight lines.
Now, there’s no point complaining about the four-person Cooper 3dr’s rear seat packaging, as there’s a massive hint in this car’s name.
But while there’s sufficient room for two larger people, the two fixed positions are best for kids only. Their backrests are a tad too upright for adult comfort. There are basically no amenities present and the side windows do not crack open. Have carmakers forgotten how? Bare and basic sums it up back there. Oh, and entry/egress is impeded by painfully slow-moving electric front seats and narrow apertures to squeeze through.
Finally, there’s the cargo area, which mirrors the previous versions with a volume of just 210 litres (VDA), rising to about 800L with the 60/40 twin backrests folded. You don’t buy a Mini for practicality. And while there’s hidden storage, no spare wheel exists, remember. Just a fiddly tyre repair kit.
Still, the Cooper’s overall cabin execution is ultra-fresh yet still reassuringly on-brand, with enough interesting new details and technologies to justify updating from an older model. An inside job well done.
Holden Spark7/10
Nope. This is a pocket-sized car, namely because it has the same cargo capacity as your pocket.
Holden has stretched the space between the wheels to maximise passenger space, and as a result there's actually plenty of room in either row. But to add space somewhere, you need to take it from somewhere else, and that somewhere else is the boot, where you'll find a mere 185-litres of luggage space. The situation is improved by dropping the 60:40 split rear seats, but you'll be forever choosing between passengers and luggage.
Front seat passengers share a pair of cupholders, but rear seat passengers get none. They don't get room for bottles in their door pockets. Or door pockets at all, for that matter. The backseat does, however, get two ISOFIX attachment points, one in each window seat.
Price and features
Mini Cooper
Now, nothing is shared between the latest petrol and electric Minis, bar mostly some dash and interior items – as well as that umbrella Cooper suffix.
While the new petrol range from the UK starts with the Cooper C 1.5-litre, three-cylinder turbo from $41,990 (all prices are before on-road costs) and from $49,990 for the Cooper S 2.0-litre, four-cylinder turbo, the EV from China kicks off from $53,990 for the Cooper E and $58,990 for the more powerful SE.
That’s about $5500 more than in the old SE electric.
Now, the two petrol Coopers come in three grades apiece (C: Core, Classic, Flavour; S: Classic, Flavour, JCW Sport), but the EV Cooper is only available in E Classic and SE Flavour for now.
In the Cooper E that means LED headlights, keyless entry/start, a head-up display, wireless charging, ambient lighting, digital radio, wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, ‘Hey, Mini’ voice control, augmented-reality navigation, 'Mini Connected Services' (via 5G connectivity), heated sports seats up front, a sports steering wheel, panoramic glass roof, piano-black trim highlights and 18-inch alloy wheels (but with no spare wheel).
Additionally, there’s a whole suite of driver-assist tech, including autonomous emergency braking (AEB) with lane-support systems, adaptive cruise control, exit warning and a surround-view camera.
Among other items, the SE adds 25kW and 40Nm of extra power and torque respectively, Harman Kardon 10-speaker audio, John Cooper Works (JCW) front seats with electric adjustment and memory for the driver, sun-protection glazing and ritzier trim.
How these compare to rival EVs of similar sizing is academic, because of the Mini’s unique positioning, reputation and lineage.
The smaller Fiat 500e for similar money, incoming Peugeot e-208 and upcoming Renault 5 EV come closest in theme, while larger hatchbacks like MG’s substantially cheaper 4, costlier Cupra Born and promising Peugeot e-308 lack the Cooper’s cool cache and contrived whimsical brashness (you decide).
As a symbol of England but with German and Greek parentage, the Mini is British royalty in more ways than one.
Holden Spark8/10
While the cheap and cheerful entry-level Spark, the $13,990 LS, plays smack-bang in the middle of the micro-car segment, the top-spec LT has bigger, and considerably more expensive, shoes to fill. At $18,990, the LT sails perilously close to its bigger and equally well-equipped competition.
For that money, the Spark needs to arrive wanting for little, and in most respects it does exactly that. For a start, a CVT automatic is standard, and is joined by some stand-out features in this segment, like cruise control, keyless entry with proximity unlocking, push-button start and a fake leather trim that Holden calls Sportec.
While navigation isn't standard, the Spark LT's seven-inch touchscreen is both Android Auto and Apple Car Play equipped, so phone maps fill the blank with ease.
Under the bonnet
Mini Cooper
Brandishing a 400-volt platform, the Cooper Electric uses an entirely different architecture (under the Spotlight joint venture with China’s Great Wall Motors or GWM) compared to the petrol-powered (and previous SE) Minis from Europe.
Mounted up front, a synchronous permanent magnet electric motor offers varying outputs depending on grade. The E makes 135kW and 290Nm, for a 0-100km/h sprint time of 7.3 seconds on the way to a top speed of 160km/h, while the sportier SE’s corresponding figures are 160kW, 330Nm, 6.7s and 170km/h. The front wheels are driven via a single-speed reduction gear transmission.
Weighing in at 1615kg and 1680kg in Euro spec, the E and SE offer a power-to-weight ratio of 83.6kW/tonne and 95.2kW/tonne, respectively.
As per other post-modern Minis, suspension is via MacPherson-style struts up front and a multi-link independent rear end. BMW also speaks of powerful brakes, a low centre of gravity, a strut brace and “preloaded stabiliser mounts on the axles”, providing enhanced handling and ride-comfort qualities.
Holden Spark7/10
There's just the one engine available across the Spark range, and that's a 1.4-litre petrol unit that'll generate 73kW and 128Nm.
Efficiency
Mini Cooper
The Cooper E features a 41kWh lithium-ion battery pack, offering a WLTP range of up to 305km, whilst the Cooper SE ups that to a larger 54kWh battery for up to 403km of range.
The WLTP combined energy consumption figure in Europe is rated between 14.3kWh/100km (E) and 14.7kWh/100km (SE). On test, the latter’s trip computer read 17.8kWh. Sadly, BMW did not provide us with an E during the soaked-out Melbourne launch event.
Three charging methods are provided: 11kW AC charging as well as either 75kW DC charging (E) and 95kW DC charging (SE). As a result, the fastest 10-80 per cent charging timings you can expect are under 5.5 hours (AC) and 30 minutes (DC).
Holden Spark8/10
Spring for the LT, and that's paired with a CVT automatic transmission, with Holden promising that combination will sip a claimed/combined 5.5L/100km (though we recorded a less impressive 8.0 litres on our test).
Driving
Mini Cooper
After all the excitement of the all-new electrified architecture and pared-back design, would the Mini Cooper Electric also impress from behind the wheel, particularly as it now hails from China rather than the UK?
We needn’t have worried - at least, not as far as the more-expensive Copper SE is concerned, as BMW did not have a base E for us to test.
First off, remember how comfortable the JCW seats are? Combined with the intuitiveness of the ergonomics, they set the driver up for an immersive and fun experience.
With 160kW, the single-motor/front-drive electric powertrain will not keep up with Tesla Model 3s costing similar money, but the Cooper SE is still tuned to feel fast off the line, responsive to your right foot inputs on the go, and rapid when you really need to leap ahead, especially in Sport mode. The latter is part of seven settings ranging from lazy cruisy to ultra-alertness. All maintain the Mini’s can-do charm.
But, as with all great super-minis in history, it's the chassis underneath that brings the electric Cooper to life.
Yes, it is heavy at 1.6 tonnes - though not for an EV with this sized battery. And, yes, the lack of a manual, integral to hot hatches for some drivers, is a drawback.
But the Mini is a taut, reactive and agile little runabout, with sharp steering that’s totally on-brand, tenacious grip (in teeming rain, too) and a level of tautness and control that just makes you feel part of the dynamic experience. Tight, alert and athletic. It’s what we expect from a Cooper and the charming, charismatic SE delivers.
Boasting such moves whilst still capable of offering a sufficiently supple ride on the standard 18-inch alloys is just as much of a joy for folks who need to commute in a Mini. The old brittle hardness of most earlier Cooper S’ has been exorcised in this affable little beauty.
We cannot tell you how quiet or otherwise the SE is on freeways as there was just too much water on the road (tyre roar is a typical German car bugbear), but the lively chassis, strong performance and impressive overall refinement are the hallmarks of the electric Mini made in China.
And, speaking of China, the handy driver-assist tech breaks from tradition by not interfering abruptly, highlighting the nuanced level of tuning BMW has performed on its petitie English patient.
Foibles? Over our two hours, we found those thick side pillars do impede vision to an alarming degree, so be grateful for the blind-spot alert. While the brakes worked magnificently, as you’d expect, we’d like some broader adjustability for the off-pedal regen braking. As it stands, it doesn’t quite bring the car to a full stop, single-pedal style. Paddle shifters to facilitate that might be nice, too.
Note, too, that another test car with two larger occupants garnered some criticism for riding too firmly. All our driving was performed with just the driver on board.
But what a drive it turned out to be. Even in high winds and torrential rain over slippery roads, the new Cooper Electric SE proved to be an irresistibly fun drive, yet with a newfound maturity that makes us impatient to get back behind that natty little wheel.
Holden Spark9/10
Holden's Aussie engineering team say they were able to get their hands all over the new Spark pre-launch, launching lap after lap of the company's proving ground as they tweaked the steering and suspension tune to better suit local conditions. And the results are very good.
The 1.4-litre engine doesn't generate a huge amount of power (though it is good for its class), but it's delivered in a way that makes the Spark feel like it's punching well above its weight, rarely feeling underpowered in everyday situations.
The Aussie magic sprinkled over the suspension and steering transforms the way the Spark LT drives, both in the city and further afield. The ride nudges the firm side of the spectrum (but not enough to bother you over inner-city ruts and bumps) which translates to a low, flat feeling through corners.
All in all, the little Spark more than holds its own on more challenging roads. The steering, too, helps the Spark outshine the regular city commuters, with a naturally engaging set-up that always feels connected to the road below.
There is a certain skittishness to the way it drives at times, though, with the gearbox wanting to continue lurching forward for a split-second after you take your foot off the accelerator, which takes some getting used to.
Safety
Mini Cooper
No crash-test ratings have yet been revealed for the new Cooper.
As mentioned earlier, there is a decent suite of driver-assist tech fitted as standard, such as AEB with lane-support systems including lane departure warning, lane keep assist and blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert/braking, rear-collision prevention, auto high beams and an exit warning. Note no AEB operating parameter data was available at the time of publishing.
Other safety features include a driver-attention monitor, adaptive cruise control (with automatic speed-limit assistance), anti-lock brakes, stability and traction controls and nine airbags (front/side/head and front centre airbags).
The Cooper also offers automatic parking assist, front parking sensors, a surround-view camera set-up, a tyre-pressure monitor and an SOS intelligent emergency call function in the event of an incapacitated driver, as part of Mini Connected Services.
There are also two child seat tether latches and twin ISOFIX anchors fitted within the rear seat.
Holden Spark8/10
Standard safety fare comes courtesy of six airbags, along with hill-hold assist, ABS and ESC, but it does miss out on more advanced technologies like autonomous brakes.
Springing for the LT will add rear parking sensors, a rear-view camera and cruise control as standard fare, though the lot can be added to the entry-level LS as part of Holden's Driver Assistance Pack.
The Spark range scored the maximum five-star ANCAP safety rating when tested early this year.
Ownership
Mini Cooper
Mini offers a five-year, unlimited kilometre warranty and five years of roadside assistance. The traction battery is also covered by an eight-year/160,000km warranty.
There are no set service intervals, as the car’s onboard computer will alert the driver based on condition and wear/tear. That said, we recommend going every 12 months or 10,000km, just to be on the safe side.
Mini promotes several prepaid service plans on its Australian website, but no details on what they are for the Cooper E/SE models were available at the time of publishing.
Holden Spark7/10
The Spark range is covered by a three-year, 100,000km warranty and requires servicing every 15,000kms. The Spark range falls under Holden's lifetime capped price servicing scheme, with trips to the dealership capped at $1,145 total for the first five services.